Resources

Make the reasoning visible.

A practice example:
Should schools start later?

01

Claim

Say what you want your audience to accept.

Schools should start later in the morning.
02

Reason

Explain why your claim might be true.

If students arrive better rested, they may find it easier to concentrate.
03

Example

Make the mechanism concrete.

Imagine a student who struggles through a first-period lesson after an early bus journey. A later start could give them more time to sleep.
04

Impact

Explain why it matters, and to whom.

Better concentration could improve the quality of learning, especially for students currently arriving tired.
Pressure-test this argument

This is an illustrative argument, not evidence that later starts always improve learning. What if students simply go to bed later? What happens to family schedules and after-school activities? A stronger case must explain why its benefits survive those objections and support factual claims with evidence.

Engage with their strongest point.

Find the assumption

What has to be true for the other side’s argument to work? In the example above, does a later school start actually produce more sleep?

Test the mechanism

Explain where the link could break. A different bedtime might reduce the benefit. Say why that is likely, rather than simply asserting it.

Compare what remains

Even if there is a benefit, how large is it? Compare it with the strongest cost, and explain whose interests should matter most.

Change your mind.
Or make it better.

THE WEEKLY MOTION

This house would ban smartphones in schools.

Try the motion yourself: make one argument for it, one against it, and explain which matters more. Read the argument guide.

One clear point.
Then another.

Use a clock to practise a two-minute speech.